RomancingCupid's Reviews
Compare online dating sites based on your needs and finding a reputable site for your dating. We are an independent directory and dating guide, featuring trusted online dating reviews. We value our independence and trusted reputation: our dating site reviews are honest, detailed and critical.
Top 10 sites

Heartdetectives Review

Reviewed by
Dr.Laura Berman
Reviewed on
Editor Rating
Membership Base
Match & Search
Cost & Prices

Pros and Cons

Like most adult dating sites, Heartdetectives has its fair choice of positive features. While it does have a few downsides, overall, the site is worth a try if membership; if you don’t mind that (approx.) about 30% of users are fakes.
A Few Hundred Thousand Users Worldwide
Has a Variety of Features
Women Can Chat for Free
3-Day Trial Available
Photo(s) and Profile Information Not Required Upon Signup.
Single Months Plans Are Expensive
A Large Percentage of Fake Profiles
No Mobile App
Isn’t active anymore

What is is one of the many adult dating sites on the web today. Having been around since 2001, Heartdetectives has a long history of being one of the oldest online dating sites and delivering services to a once thriving and no-longer-growing community of singles. Although it’s not completely free for any members, the site still gives them a lot of paid features for free, which is probably why the site’s demographic still exists after 19 years.

Member Structure

Heartdetectives offers both free & paid accounts to all of its members. Male members benefit more from upgrading, as (unlike the female members), they do not have unlimited replies. Instead, they get five free chats, which have to be sent to different members. Free accounts are also able to send Hearts, add members to their Favorites list, and upload photos. When a user upgrades, they have unlimited messaging, send photos/videos via chat, use extended search features, and more!

Heartdetectives App

As one of the older adult dating sites, Heartdetectives definitely had the option of making a dedicated application, but it chose not to. Instead, Heartdetectives has a mobile-optimized version of the site, which often uses primarily icons instead of words. This works relatively well on mobile devices & includes the same features as the desktop version. While a dedicated app would have been nice, the mobile version can be used on any mobile device, which is a plus.

Costs and Prices

As mentioned above, Heartdetectives offers both free & paid memberships. Free users can only use basic features, while premium members have access to everything. For females, this could be considered optional, but for the men it’s a necessity. We recommend purchasing the longer 3-month plan, as the cost-per-month is lower. Heartdetectives also offers a paid 3-day trial to test out the services.
Duration Costs Total
3-Day Trial $ 5 $ 5
1 month $30.00 / month $30.00
3 month $20.00 / month $60.00

Heartdetectives Special Features

Free Account Registration
LGBT-Friendly Site
Plenty of Tools to Find Personal Relationships
A Large Member base
Free Replies
Sending Hearts (Which Are Similar to Likes)
Active Site Moderators


Heartdetectives doesn’t have a variety of security measures in place. Only things you have include the ability to block members, a “report” button, and.. that’s it. Account verification, photo verification, and Safe Mode are nonexistent; the site doesn’t let you control who can message you.

Our Experience

Sign up Process

The homepage has a short signup form, which you will need to complete in order to make an account. To do this, you will need to provide your gender, sexual orientation, age, email, and location. You will also need to pick a password. Make sure that you have access to the email you use because it will be used for account verification.

Profile Creation

Once you’ve filled out the signup form, you will be greeted with a congratulatory message informing you that it’s time to verify your account. To do this, go to the email you supplied, open up the inbox, find the email from Heartdetectives, and click on the link inside the email to verify your account. From here, you can upload a profile photo and then add account details. Many users don’t bother to complete their profiles, so it’s an easy way to stand out from the crowd!

Searching and Matchmaking

Searching to find your match on Heartdetectives is a very straightforward process. The search bar provides you with a variety of filters (such as sexual orientation or body type), making it easy to find your dream partner. Since the profiles can contain some very personal information for you to review, this helps you find someone who’s a perfect match. If searching isn’t yielding many results, you can also try your luck and simply look who’s nearby.

Contacting with Other Members

Messaging on Heartdetectives is similar to most online dating sites. You can send basic text messages, but this site also allows you to share pictures via chat as well. Free male users only get five free chats to send (which must be sent to different members). Free female users get the five free chats but can continue to reply for free. Once a member upgrades to a paid membership, they have access to unlimited messaging. However, since men usually message women (not the other way around), upgrading makes more sense for men than it does for women.

Experts Conclusion

If you’re looking to form personal connections & find real relationships, then we definitely don’t recommend Heartdetectives. Especially if you’re a man, it offers access to a massive online community of singles looking for love, but the result is scam accounts preying upon singles seeking matches. You won’t have any trouble finding yourself a lady, but will she be real? Probably not. The site ignores any approach to online safety, so you can’t feel secure when using this website. As of now, it doesn’t seem to work due to a server error. Will it be resurrected as something greater, or is the platform dead? Only time will tell.


Who owns

Heartdetectives is owned & operated by Heartdetectives INC. The website has been active since 2001

How do I renew my Heartdetectives full membership?

Your Heartdetectives membership will renew automatically, so you don’t need to worry about forgetting to pay. However, we do recommend purchasing an extended membership plan to lower the monthly costs.

Can I block another Heartdetectives member?

Yes - it’s actually quite simple! Go to the user’s profile, click on the three vertical dots on the right side of the page, then select “Block.”